Printable SudokuOnline List Maker

Online List Maker › Printable sudoku › Sudoku difficulty levels

What Makes a Sudoku Hard?

The common belief is that a sudoku with fewer starting numbers is harder. We tested it on 9,740 puzzles. More clues do make a puzzle more likely to be easy, but they are a weak guide to whether it is hard; what decides that is the hardest technique the puzzle forces you to use.

55%

of the 24-clue puzzles (the fewest in our run) were Easy: solvable with singles alone.

22%

of the 32-clue puzzles (the most generous) still needed Hard or Expert techniques or more. At 24 clues it was 25%.

67%

of all 9,740 puzzles were Easy. Hard were 4%, Expert 5%, and 15% needed more than our solver uses (chains or trial and error) and were left out of the printable sets.

Difficulty by number of starting clues

Each row is every puzzle in our run with that many starting numbers, split by the level our solver gave it. More clues clearly make Easy puzzles more common (55% at 24 clues, up to 75% higher up), mostly at the expense of Medium (20% at 24 clues, under 10% from 28 up). But the share that needs Hard or Expert techniques or more falls only slowly: 25% of puzzles with 24 to 27 clues, 22% of those with 28 to 32. More than one generous puzzle in five is still a hard one.

What this does and doesn't show: clue count here is an outcome of how the puzzles were made (clues come out until no more can go), not something we set, so the result describes puzzles made this way, between 24 and 32 clues. The 31- and 32-clue rows hold only about 100 puzzles each, so their percentages can be off by several points.

EasyMediumHardExpertNeeds guessing or chains (left out)
Starting cluesPuzzlesEasyMediumHardExpertLeft out
2426855%20%4%3%17%
2530955%14%5%8%18%
262,44763%12%4%4%16%
271,02165%11%5%5%15%
283,69669%8%4%5%14%
2958770%8%4%5%13%
301,17772%6%3%5%14%
3110975%7%2%4%12%
3210270%9%8%3%11%

Rows with fewer than 50 puzzles are left out (22 clues: 2, 23 clues: 17, 33 clues: 4, 34 clues: 1).

How we made and graded them

  1. Fill a random complete 9×9 grid.
  2. Take clues away in pairs that are symmetric under a half-turn of the grid (the classic newspaper look), checking after each removal that the puzzle still has exactly one solution, until no pair can go.
  3. Solve it the way a person does: always use the simplest technique that makes progress, from singles up through pairs, triples, X-wing, XY-wing, swordfish, XYZ-wing and simple coloring (all thirteen, explained).
  4. The level is the hardest technique that was needed: Easy (singles), Medium (pointing, box-line, pairs), Hard (triples, X-wing, XY-wing), Expert (swordfish, XYZ-wing, coloring). Puzzles that still could not be finished need longer chains or trial and error; we counted them and left them out of the printable sets.

Every step the solver takes is a certain deduction, and we checked it: across all 9,740 puzzles, no placement or elimination ever contradicted the puzzle’s one true solution. Clues ran from 22 to 34; most landed between 24 and 32 because of how the removal stops. Even counts (26, 28, 30) are commoner than odd ones because clues leave two at a time; only the centre square, its own partner, can make the count odd.

So why do puzzles with fewer clues feel harder?

They take longer: more squares to fill means more steps, and a few more of them need a pair or a pointing move. But longer is not harder. A puzzle becomes hard at the moment the easy tools stop working, and that can happen in a puzzle with plenty of numbers on the page. That is why our Easy sheets use only singles-solvable puzzles and give extra clues, while our Hard and Expert sheets are chosen by technique alone.

Print by real difficulty

Questions

Does fewer clues make a sudoku harder?

Not by much. In our run of 9,740 puzzles, 55% of those with 24 clues were still solvable with singles alone, and 22% of those with 28 to 32 clues still needed Hard or Expert techniques or more (against 25% at 24 to 27). Difficulty is set by the hardest technique a puzzle requires.

What is the minimum number of clues in a sudoku?

Seventeen. In 2012 Gary McGuire, Bastian Tugemann and Gilles Civario showed by an exhaustive computer search that no 16-clue sudoku has a unique solution. Puzzles made by taking clues away one pair at a time, like ours, almost always stop well above that: the fewest in our run had 22.

How are sudoku difficulty levels decided?

Good puzzle makers grade by solving technique: a computer solves the puzzle the way a person would, and the level is the hardest step it needed. Grading by clue count alone puts some easy puzzles in the hard pile and the other way round.